Great post, Marcus - been looking forward to this one!
My experience has been very similar. I think many people underestimate how ambivalent students are about tech, how much many of them dislike both AI and ed tech, and how much many of them dislike AI as ed tech specifically. Thinking about things that I've seen/heard from my students (for context, I teach at an urban technical community college with a majority BIPOC student body):
- My students generally see the big-picture impact of AI in negative terms: job losses, environmental damage, slop, deepfakes, surveillance tech, etc. I've been struck by the degree to which my students are aware of the problems with e.g. facial recognition technology.
- A lot of this is very strongly felt. For many students of color especially, the use of AI as surveillance tech is very personal. For many female students especially, the use of AI to generate deepfake porn is very personal. For many students who are invested in art and creativity, or even in different fandoms, the use of AI to create slop art (etc.) is very personal. Etc.
- My students mostly don't have a lot of love for ed tech in general. It seems to be something that they experience more as a hurdle than a help, and the more something is mediated through layers of technology, the less likely they are to engage/the more likely they are to view it as busy work. (And the more they view it as busy work, the more likely they are to hand it off to AI.)
- My sense is that this is especially true of students who experienced online school during COVID. Students have told me how they felt disconnected, even abandoned, when school was online and how they essentially checked out. There's a pretty deep skepticism that more tech > more learning.
- This is *not* to say that my students don't see problems with schools as they have experienced them! To be frank, I've heard some pretty grim stuff from students about their past educational experiences. Not just lack of resources (though that, too), but a culture driven by compliance and surveillance, with a lack of trust, respect, and meaningful learning.
- The thing is, my students tend to see tech as a part of that, rather than a solution to that. To give just one example, I remember talking with a young Black man about his experience in high school and how college was going for him. He said, "You know one thing I like about this place?" and pointed up to the corner above the door, where something, from his perspective, was notably absent. "No cameras."
- Against this background, all of the energy that's going into AI-oriented surveillance is having a really negative effect. AI checkers, browser lockdowns, keyboard trackers, requirements that students be on camera when they do online assignments. Students hate this stuff, and understandably so. They recognize that it's happening in response to AI, and my sense is that it's part of what drives their negative sentiment toward AI, but it also corrodes their relationship with their teachers/professors.
- Overall, my sense is that students' views on AI reflect an experience of alienation. They connect AI in the world with a larger experience of dispossession and disempowerment. They connect AI in education with a larger experience of disconnection and distrust. And when they use AI for school, the fact that they're using it and the way that they're using it largely reflects their alienation from their education. That's not to say that I don't have students who are AI enthusiasts, because I do, typically maybe one a class. But for the great majority, as you say, the fact that they may use it in certain circumstances doesn't necessarily mean that they like what it's doing to their education.
- In spite of all this, most of my students really care about their education. They hope it will make a meaningful difference in their lives, but they also want it to be a meaningful experience in itself. In teaching classes where students have a lot of latitude to decide what they want to write about, I've been struck by (a) how many students make decisions that are driven more by personal interest than career preparation and (b) how many students choose to write about education. They care, and they want to see that we care. And your students clearly do!
Genuinely appreciate all of this, because I think two things can be true at once: students are ambivalent about AI's impact on their education as far as learning, especially in the context of EdTech; AND there can be some deeper ethical and societal issues also driving student skepticism and resistance.
That you lay out both here is not to say it is one or the other, but that both are simultaneously present in all of our classrooms—whether we choose to see it or not.
Thanks, Marcus. Really appreciated your post, and it's clear that your students really appreciate the experience that they're having in your classroom. Happy running!
Thanks for sharing these insights. Interestingly, in my class that is all about AI, I'm also finding that the more students know about AI, the more questions/concerns they have.
Yep! For me one of the most important takeaways was the distinction between usage and appreciation—which I think a lot of the conversation tends to leave out. (And why the piece you featured last week about the pressure on students to use it just to keep up was so important, too!)
The students have it right in that the time and place to learn responsible AI use is not their English class. I find it interesting that they already know the risks of letting the fox into the henhouse with only the gossamer leash of policies/guidelines is totally ineffective because people are given to shortcuts by nature. You see it all the time in adults who received extensive analog training in critical thinking and are now running to AI for things they could do with two minutes of actual thought. Students seem to know that without the experience of producing analytical outputs and receiving feedback on them they will be wholly reliant on whatever AI spits out to them, which is exactly the outcome AI execs are hoping for, even as they send their own kids to tech-free waldorf academies teaching rigorous socratic dialogue in kindergarten.
This! As much as I think it's important to broaden the conversation here, I also think the narrowness of my ELA context matters just as much—and this is why I'm quite open-minded about standalone AI Literacy options or how it might be implemented in other content areas.
At the end of the day, I trust teachers to do what is best for their context! But I am quite resistant to decrees from above or "vibe pressure" to push us in a direction we do not have evidence to support—and, even worse, in a direction students actively say is the wrong one.
Great piece! I appreciate your commitment to elevating student voice. People who understand adolescent development and have spent time working with students know that students value authenticity. I’ll avoid over generalizing but I am not surprised that students feel this way. It mirrors my own experience as a school counselor.
Appreciate your share here, and I have zero doubt that as a school counselor you get to better understand how far more classrooms are going through the eyes and voices of students—one of the reasons our conversations are much better when they're had with different vantage points and contexts, I think!
Agreed. When you are trained to listen with intention, you hear everyone’s stories. I often joke that school counselors are there for the adults too. I love and welcome the collaboration. Teachers helped me become a better educator and those teachers have also valued my input.
100% agree with that idea! The counseling team at my school is a consistent go-to for many adults, and they wear "many hats" in their service to our school community.
Being "trained to listen with intention" can be a rising tide in any school community, I think!
For me what matters most is (a) students finding their learning experiences to be meaningful and (b) students getting a chance to have their voices heard—so this feels like a win/win from my vantage point.
(And that remains true if they have different perspectives, too—as was the case when they suggested a different path with one of our reading selections! 😂)
There is without question a broader trend of a disconnect between the adults in positions of power in education and the majority of students and other stakeholders right now—and I fear it's only going to get worse in the coming year if there isn't a lot more listening that takes place...
With its current trajectory, your students will not be able to afford AI services within one year. So, either the school district has to afford that very expensive service (not so much now but will be in one year), or you are advantaging the rich kids over the rest.
Great post, Marcus - been looking forward to this one!
My experience has been very similar. I think many people underestimate how ambivalent students are about tech, how much many of them dislike both AI and ed tech, and how much many of them dislike AI as ed tech specifically. Thinking about things that I've seen/heard from my students (for context, I teach at an urban technical community college with a majority BIPOC student body):
- My students generally see the big-picture impact of AI in negative terms: job losses, environmental damage, slop, deepfakes, surveillance tech, etc. I've been struck by the degree to which my students are aware of the problems with e.g. facial recognition technology.
- A lot of this is very strongly felt. For many students of color especially, the use of AI as surveillance tech is very personal. For many female students especially, the use of AI to generate deepfake porn is very personal. For many students who are invested in art and creativity, or even in different fandoms, the use of AI to create slop art (etc.) is very personal. Etc.
- My students mostly don't have a lot of love for ed tech in general. It seems to be something that they experience more as a hurdle than a help, and the more something is mediated through layers of technology, the less likely they are to engage/the more likely they are to view it as busy work. (And the more they view it as busy work, the more likely they are to hand it off to AI.)
- My sense is that this is especially true of students who experienced online school during COVID. Students have told me how they felt disconnected, even abandoned, when school was online and how they essentially checked out. There's a pretty deep skepticism that more tech > more learning.
- This is *not* to say that my students don't see problems with schools as they have experienced them! To be frank, I've heard some pretty grim stuff from students about their past educational experiences. Not just lack of resources (though that, too), but a culture driven by compliance and surveillance, with a lack of trust, respect, and meaningful learning.
- The thing is, my students tend to see tech as a part of that, rather than a solution to that. To give just one example, I remember talking with a young Black man about his experience in high school and how college was going for him. He said, "You know one thing I like about this place?" and pointed up to the corner above the door, where something, from his perspective, was notably absent. "No cameras."
- Against this background, all of the energy that's going into AI-oriented surveillance is having a really negative effect. AI checkers, browser lockdowns, keyboard trackers, requirements that students be on camera when they do online assignments. Students hate this stuff, and understandably so. They recognize that it's happening in response to AI, and my sense is that it's part of what drives their negative sentiment toward AI, but it also corrodes their relationship with their teachers/professors.
- Overall, my sense is that students' views on AI reflect an experience of alienation. They connect AI in the world with a larger experience of dispossession and disempowerment. They connect AI in education with a larger experience of disconnection and distrust. And when they use AI for school, the fact that they're using it and the way that they're using it largely reflects their alienation from their education. That's not to say that I don't have students who are AI enthusiasts, because I do, typically maybe one a class. But for the great majority, as you say, the fact that they may use it in certain circumstances doesn't necessarily mean that they like what it's doing to their education.
- In spite of all this, most of my students really care about their education. They hope it will make a meaningful difference in their lives, but they also want it to be a meaningful experience in itself. In teaching classes where students have a lot of latitude to decide what they want to write about, I've been struck by (a) how many students make decisions that are driven more by personal interest than career preparation and (b) how many students choose to write about education. They care, and they want to see that we care. And your students clearly do!
Genuinely appreciate all of this, because I think two things can be true at once: students are ambivalent about AI's impact on their education as far as learning, especially in the context of EdTech; AND there can be some deeper ethical and societal issues also driving student skepticism and resistance.
That you lay out both here is not to say it is one or the other, but that both are simultaneously present in all of our classrooms—whether we choose to see it or not.
Thanks, Marcus. Really appreciated your post, and it's clear that your students really appreciate the experience that they're having in your classroom. Happy running!
Thank you! As luck would have it, I was working on a post about my handle when you made this comment
Cool - I'll have to check it out! (Big scratch paper proponent myself.)
You definitely have a post here. Great stuff
Thanks! Great handle, by the way!
Thanks for sharing these insights. Interestingly, in my class that is all about AI, I'm also finding that the more students know about AI, the more questions/concerns they have.
Yep! For me one of the most important takeaways was the distinction between usage and appreciation—which I think a lot of the conversation tends to leave out. (And why the piece you featured last week about the pressure on students to use it just to keep up was so important, too!)
The students have it right in that the time and place to learn responsible AI use is not their English class. I find it interesting that they already know the risks of letting the fox into the henhouse with only the gossamer leash of policies/guidelines is totally ineffective because people are given to shortcuts by nature. You see it all the time in adults who received extensive analog training in critical thinking and are now running to AI for things they could do with two minutes of actual thought. Students seem to know that without the experience of producing analytical outputs and receiving feedback on them they will be wholly reliant on whatever AI spits out to them, which is exactly the outcome AI execs are hoping for, even as they send their own kids to tech-free waldorf academies teaching rigorous socratic dialogue in kindergarten.
This! As much as I think it's important to broaden the conversation here, I also think the narrowness of my ELA context matters just as much—and this is why I'm quite open-minded about standalone AI Literacy options or how it might be implemented in other content areas.
At the end of the day, I trust teachers to do what is best for their context! But I am quite resistant to decrees from above or "vibe pressure" to push us in a direction we do not have evidence to support—and, even worse, in a direction students actively say is the wrong one.
Great piece! I appreciate your commitment to elevating student voice. People who understand adolescent development and have spent time working with students know that students value authenticity. I’ll avoid over generalizing but I am not surprised that students feel this way. It mirrors my own experience as a school counselor.
Appreciate your share here, and I have zero doubt that as a school counselor you get to better understand how far more classrooms are going through the eyes and voices of students—one of the reasons our conversations are much better when they're had with different vantage points and contexts, I think!
Agreed. When you are trained to listen with intention, you hear everyone’s stories. I often joke that school counselors are there for the adults too. I love and welcome the collaboration. Teachers helped me become a better educator and those teachers have also valued my input.
100% agree with that idea! The counseling team at my school is a consistent go-to for many adults, and they wear "many hats" in their service to our school community.
Being "trained to listen with intention" can be a rising tide in any school community, I think!
This is positive news--I hope the kids maintain this skeptical attitude as they continue their education!
For me what matters most is (a) students finding their learning experiences to be meaningful and (b) students getting a chance to have their voices heard—so this feels like a win/win from my vantage point.
(And that remains true if they have different perspectives, too—as was the case when they suggested a different path with one of our reading selections! 😂)
This is so fascinating! Thank you for sharing. I wish I’d done a similar survey with my students. I bet the results would be the exact same.
It makes me think of that commencement speech when all the graduates booed the speaker when she mentioned AI, much to her surprise.
People who think AI belongs in schools don’t interact with students much, do they?
Also, happy summer! Good luck with the running :)
There is without question a broader trend of a disconnect between the adults in positions of power in education and the majority of students and other stakeholders right now—and I fear it's only going to get worse in the coming year if there isn't a lot more listening that takes place...
With its current trajectory, your students will not be able to afford AI services within one year. So, either the school district has to afford that very expensive service (not so much now but will be in one year), or you are advantaging the rich kids over the rest.