17 Comments
User's avatar
Meg's avatar

"I am just as confident for now in my own choice to avoid bringing AI as a tool into our classroom. The costs are simply not worth it." Amen to this 👏

Katie (Kathryn) Conrad's avatar

Love your sketch notes! Why the heck don’t I take notes like this? I’m going to now! (I’ve always been a mediocre notetaker. I wish I had you as a teacher!)

I am honored to show up in this reflection given what a jam-packed and amazing gathering it was - including your great and thought provoking session that I’m totally stealing ideas from. It was really a fantastic couple of days, wasn’t it? Kudos to Mike and the team!

I just started to write a bunch of points of agreement and have deleted two paragraphs that I think can just be summarized with “what he said.” 👆

(And I was working on the collaborative workshop collage zine last night. Coming soon!)

Marcus Luther's avatar

A collage-zine activity is part of my opening lesson for our mini-critical AI literacy sequence this year! And very much leaning on yours and Sean's resources in going back through and strengthening a lot of the conversational touch points that I hit last year, too—so very grateful of what your presentation offered as far as resources but also mindsets!

Katie (Kathryn) Conrad's avatar

Oh yay! I’d love to know how it goes!

Windows to the World's avatar

1. The doodle web notes are great!

2. I really appreciate the nuance of your AI reflections and plans to share more moving forward. I’m an AI hater but hoping to more directly address AI literacy and what’s at stake if students take the shortcut.

3. I wonder what schools taking ownership for the conditions they’ve created for students would look like…

Marcus Luther's avatar

That third question! I also think this goes far beyond just AI, too—but I do think a collective sense of accountability would be a great first step.

Stephen Fitzpatrick's avatar

Thanks for the shout out, Marcus and I have also been curious about the takeaways from your conference - we need more of these gatherings and opportunities for teachers from around the country and across the spectrum to come talk about teaching (which may or may not include AI!) and I think the grass roots efforts of educators like the group that pulled this conference together is a net positive of what AI has forced teachers and students alike to confront. I was also glad to see student voices included and that one quote captures the essence of where students are caught - most not having been given any sort of guidance or instruction on how AI works, what it is, and where it may or may not belong in the learning process means they are figuring it out on their own and we shouldn't be surprised some are getting dependent. The most thoughtful (and most kids are! We shouldn't forget that!) will come to the realization that in the long run over reliance is not helping them. I have been interviewing college students for an upcoming post (hopefully) about what students should expect when they matriculate this fall and the huge takeaway is AI is totally normalized in college - for good and for ill. I don't buy any longer that many students don't use AI at least for some things and many kids are grappling with just how far they can and should go - it varies enormously by school, discipline, and individual professors, but all of them are using AI in some ways. That makes it all the more important that we keep them grounded in the classroom while we have them in K-12 - the much less personal touchpoints most college classrooms have with students means AI use increases - at least that's what students are telling me, but the best college professors can still influence students to use their brain. Anyway, I'm sure this was interesting and I've been trying to pull something similar together on the east coast for awhile - hopefully next summer. Keep up the good work!

Marcus Luther's avatar

Oh, sign me up for that post built around interviewing college students—I have zero doubt about the normalization, too, and I also don't presume that there's a single policy or even set of norms that is commensurate with this moment and its shifting sands.

But more/better conversation, especially across perspectives and contexts? Feels sort of like the only path—and one of the cool things about this conference is that I think it is a replicable model!

Michael Burns's avatar

Love this synthesis of where you are these days, Marcus! Thanks for sharing. I'm forwarding this to our English department and Admin.

Marcus Luther's avatar

Hopefully Marist isn't a Cornell Notes school... 😂

Robert Glasner's avatar

Marcus, the distinction between AI literacy and critical AI literacy is important.

I would add one student test: before asking AI, form your own view. After AI responds, identify what you accept, what you reject, and what you verified.

That keeps AI literacy from quietly becoming AI dependence.

Brett Vogelsinger's avatar

What an excellent reflection, Marcus, and as always a model of what deep thinking about the work of our profession can yield. Feels like we (the readers) were right beside you at this memorable gathering 😊

Steffen Rentschler's avatar

You clearly paid close attention at the conference. Now all that’s missing is the report on what you actually learned there. 😂

Marcus Luther's avatar

Not really sure of the purpose of this comment, particularly in what seems like an intentional looking-past what was actually written here, but oh well. The internet is going to internet sometimes...

Steffen Rentschler's avatar

I did read what you wrote. My comment was admittedly pointed, but my confusion is genuine: I still cannot identify a clear definition of “critical AI literacy,” concrete learning objectives, or an argument connecting your conference reflections to your decision not to use AI as a tool in class. Your sketches document a thought process, but they do not clarify that connection for the reader. If I have overlooked the central argument, I would honestly be interested to know where you think it is.

Marcus Luther's avatar

Fair enough—much easier to respond to this, I think!

(1) My overarching reflections and mindsets were what I walked away with, and are different than "learning objectives" for the classroom—and I think it's important to start there as adult educators before we move into what concrete, student-facing objectives would look like.

(2) I also didn't want to lift direct resources from the presentations into the post, which is why for example I gave my own takeaway regarding critical AI literacy and what distinguishes it from other forms. Here is an example of a more direct resource on this: https://academyforeducationalstudies.org/wp-content/uploads/2025/09/conrad-kamperman-final-1.pdf

(3) As far as the decision to not use AI, I linked to my post from earlier this summer that lays out the full reasoning, including student feedback. But I also provided this in the context of a student sharing how AI took away their own confidence in their writing, which I think is an incisively clear example of the cost of our rush towards AI implementation in schools.

Again, fully recognize that when I type something out and blast it out into the ether, it might not land for everyone! 100% okay, and also why The Broken Copier is 100% free—and also 100% free to unsubscribe, too :)

Steffen Rentschler's avatar

Fair enough - and thank you for the detailed explanation.

I can see now that I read your post with the wrong set of expectations: I treated it as a professional article intended to develop a clearly defined concept and argument, rather than as a personal reflection following a conference.

I also probably projected some of my own experiences with educational conferences onto your account: lots of conversation—which can certainly be enjoyable- an exchange of what often seemed like familiar pedagogical commonplaces, and then returning home with a rather diffuse sense of having reflected deeply without being entirely sure what had actually been learned.

On rereading your post, I see that you criticize the conventional conference format yourself, while describing this particular conference as a positive exception because of the panels, debriefs, and conversations. My first comment was therefore not only pointed, but aimed at the wrong target. If it came across as personal, I’m sorry.

Thank you for taking the time to explain your intention and for providing the additional link. I have now started reading the paper.

One small irony amused me: the paper warns that LLMs produce statistically probable responses, yet it follows an extraordinarily familiar pattern of critical-pedagogy conference reports. Replace “AI” with social media, smartphones, advertising, or almost any other technology, and much of the definition, structure, and conclusion would survive unchanged: place the technology within systems of power, create space for reflection and dialogue, report that participants valued the exchange, and conclude that more such opportunities are needed.

Perhaps human and machinegenerated texts are sometimes less different than we like to think. 😂

But you won’t get rid of me as a subscriber quite that easily.